Home Base: Boulder, Colorado
Author’s Take: “I didn’t set out to write about the Marias Massacre. I did set out to come at the buffalo hunters, and I knew that I wanted to take them down on the page over and over again, just punish them the way they had punished the herds, and by association, us.”
Favourite Line: “What I am is the Indian who can’t die. I’m the worst dream America ever had.”
Review: I have long been a fan of Blackfeet Native American writer and teacher Stephen Graham Jones – I firmly believe him to be one of the finest writers working in the horror genre today. Even that fondness, however, did little to prepare me for just how bowled over I would be by his new novel.
The Buffalo Hunter Hunter is a nested novel. It begins in 2012, when “a day worker reaches into the wall of the parsonage his crew’s revamping and pulls a piece of history up.” It’s a journal written by Arthur Beaucarne, a Lutheran pastor in Miles City, Montana, preserved for a century. The journal makes its way to Etsy Beaucarne, his great-great-great-granddaughter, a struggling academic, who, after establishing some historical context, begins to transcribe the document.
Beaucarne the pastor, haunted by his past, writes of his encounters with a mysterious “Indian gentleman,” who attends services in black clerical robes and dark glasses, and who inveigles Beaucarne to hear his confession. The narrative then shifts between the visitor – Good Stab – who recounts the events of his life, and Beaucarne, who finds his own life increasingly affected by both the historical tragedies he is hearing about and by the monstrous entity that is Good Stab himself. Good Stab, you see, can’t die, and he can survive only by drinking blood, which he obtains, in the main, from the white hunters who are massacring the buffalo herds, taking their skins and leaving the meat to rot.
While initially somewhat daunting – Good Stab’s language and worldview may frustrate readers early on – The Buffalo Hunter Hunter is both a dazzling achievement, and a powerful, compelling read. While the novel is historical, documenting the western conquest from an underheard perspective, it manages to bring that history into the present. “The past,” as Faulkner once said, “is never dead. It isn’t even past.” Jones achieves this feat through a fidelity to both the history itself and to his characters: The Buffalo Hunter Hunter is at times brutally violent, while at the same time achingly sad, blood-soaked and tragic, horrifying and heartbreaking.
It’s not just Jones’ masterpiece, nor is it simply a horror masterpiece: it’s a full-fledged masterpiece, full-stop, and likely one of the finest novels you will read this year. —Robert Wiersema