“When I was a young actor, I was Thug No. 1 or Thug No. 2, and then after a while I refused to do that,” says the veteran Canadian star, Shawn Doyle. “Then everything opened up for me because I took a chance on myself.” Focusing on leading man roles not only led to his starring turn on the early 2000s Canadian drama The Eleventh Hour but to multi-episode arcs in U.S. shows that defined that same era: Desperate Housewives, 24, Lost, Big Love, House of Cards and Fargo. Fast forward to this year, and Doyle plays pivotal roles in the most recent season of Prime’s Reacher and in the Netflix thriller Below – two of the top-rated and buzziest series of the year.

Doyle
There’s no pigeonholing Shawn Doyle, who played a former NHLer and single dad in the Newfoundland indie film, Grown Up Movie Star; and a small-town chief of police in the first season of FX’s Fargo.  | Alamy

So it’s funny that in the midst of his current high-profile run, you can see Doyle play Donny in David Mamet’s American Buffalo at the intensely intimate 100-seat Coal Mine Theatre in the far east end of Toronto (until Dec. 6). “In that space you can be distracted by just the most subtle movements from people in the audience,” Doyle tells Zoomer. “But it’s also rewarding because if the audience is engaged, you feel that connection with them immediately. It’s just very palpable and much of the story kind of hinges on the choices that the characters are making internally. And when you’re in a space that small, you can trust that you can think and you can work out that stuff and the audience will see it, as opposed to having to be more performative.”

Doyle takes on David Mamet’s sharp dialogue in a small Toronto theatre production of American Buffalo. | Elana Emer Photography

The story takes place over the course of one night as three would-be crooks plot out a robbery. “In theatre school, in our late teens and early 20s, a lot of guys would gravitate to Mamet,” says Doyle. “His work seemed to embody a kind of masculinity we were supposed to take on, but hadn’t – they talked sharp and they acted sharp.” For Doyle, this struggle was also homegrown. “I had come from Newfoundland, from a mining town [in Labrador], and there’s a very specific sense of what men were supposed to be, which I never fell into – thankfully my dad didn’t either.” Coming back to Mamet and this play at 58, the Toronto-based actor sees things more clearly: “The plays are really just about friendship and loyalty and love and trust and how men are looking for those things. It’s really about how if you make these choices in life to get what you think you’re owed and have over on someone else, then what you lose is love. It’s great to come to this decades later with so much more perspective.”

While he thrives on career variety – TV, film and theatre; in Canada and in the U.S.; leading roles and supporting parts – Doyle admits that working solely in his home province of Newfoundland and Labrador would be the dream, especially after his experience on Below. The project was so huge, says Doyle, “There were all these locations of inlets and bays and they would fly over these areas with drones and determine what looked good for a location and then they’d have to build roads to get to it. It’s amazing the money they spent and most of it shows up on screen. It’s really incredible to be part of a show about Newfoundland that has that kind of production value.” 

Clockwise from top: Doyle plays Walton in Below and provides a key to the mystery of the sea monster; with the star of the series, Josh Hartnett; and on the red carpet at TIFF this year for the show’s premiere. | Courtesy of Netflix© 2026

Even though Doyle enjoyed mixing it up with fellow Newfoundland actors (Natasha Henstridge and Mary Walsh) and Hollywood stars trying out maritime accents (Josh Hartnett and Mackenzie Davis), he said they never expected Below to reach No. 1 on Netflix in 53 countries. “The show does an incredible job of really conveying the authenticity of outport life. Newfoundlanders look at that and go, ‘Yeah, that’s right,’” says Doyle. “I think everybody was so excited that such a big project was going to represent our culture and everybody has a piece of ownership in it. That’s what it felt like.” On a personal note, it was a full-circle moment for Doyle, whose dad, also an actor, played Gordon Pinsent’s best friend in a 1987 movie called John and the Missus, which, like Below, is about Newfoundland’s outport relocation programs. “That storyline is very potent, and relevant to my character, in Below, and I felt really privileged to do something my dad had already done 40 years ago.”

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Shawn Doyle (@shawnydoyle)

Doyle admits that earlier in his career he would have passed on a project like Below, due to his own version of a Newfoundland relocation. “I left home at 16 [to be an actor] and when you went away, you couldn’t really come back and not be judged for it. ‘Oh, yeah, buddy went away, look at him, he’s right grand now,’” he says. “And so I was afraid to come back for the longest time and also because I grew up in Labrador as opposed to the island of Newfoundland, I always kind of felt a bit of an outsider. I was never part of the island theatre community. I was asked many, many times to go back when I was in L.A. shooting Big Love and always said no, mostly out of fear.” But after being offered a part so good he couldn’t refuse – Adriana Maggs’s 2010 film Grown Up Movie Star with a young Tatiana Maslany (Orphan Black) – he says, “I came back to film in Newfoundland and it kind of cracked me open, cracked open my heart, and all that stuff that I’d run away from has since made me the actor I am today.” One that has come a long way from Thug No. 1 and is currently looking for full-time work on The Rock.

Handout