Of the six million Canadians who live with arthritis, more than four million have been diagnosed with osteoarthritis, making it the most common form of the chronically painful condition that many of us know all too well. 

Osteoarthritis, which becomes significantly more common as we age, usually affects the knees, hips and hands, and it causes stiffness, swelling and pain, thanks to changes in the joint tissue, like cartilage loss. Often billed as the “wear-and-tear” disease, we tend to think of our joints as, say, brake pads, which we wear down the more we use them. 

But that’s not quite the case. “That framing is backwards, and it may actually be doing people harm,” says Dr. Tom Appleton, the division head of rheumatology at St. Joseph’s Health Care in London, Ont., and an associate professor in the Department of Medicine, Department of Physiology and Pharmacology at Western University. Instead, he says the safest way to protect your joints is to move. “Across the board, the research favours safe physical activity of essentially any kind (including swimming and walking) over a sedentary lifestyle when it comes to joint health. Movement isn’t the enemy of arthritic pain – inactivity is a much bigger risk.” 

If you suffer from osteoarthritis and deal with ongoing soreness, inflammation, swelling, decreased range of motion and stiffness in your joints, you’ve likely asked your healthcare provider for every tip and trick in the book to ease the discomfort and chronic pain. Perhaps they’ve given you the same advice Appleton shares about staying mobile, or maybe they’ve handed you the typical physio and occupational therapy prescriptions, recommended weight management or suggested over-the-counter pain meds, analgesics or even cortisone injections.

Getty Images

And if you’ve wondered why they haven’t mentioned treatments like glucosamine, Turmeric or fish oil – it’s probably because these dietary supplements are a particularly prickly topic with physicians. 

Dr. Gillian Hawker, a professor of medicine in the Department of Medicine, Division of Rheumatology at the University of Toronto, is a skeptic when it comes to supplements to help osteoarthritic pain. She mentions the lack of blinding of study participants (this means people know whether they’re taking the drug or placebo and those who get the drug respond differently to osteoarthritis symptoms), the fact that most clinical trials are industry funded, that there are generally a small number of study participants and there’s a lack of data on adverse side effects. “This means that some of these agents may be useful, but we just don’t have enough information and, if there is not strong evidence to support the safety and benefit of an intervention and the cost is great, they should be considered only when recommended therapies have been tried,” Hawker says.  

Experts seem to agree that as a general approach, we should be wary of supplements. However, some say a select few supplements show data that suggests modest pain relief. While Dr. Jason McDougall, professor in the departments of pharmacology and anaesthesia at Dalhousie University in Halifax, agrees that many supplements seem to have little to no effect, he’s from the school of thought that some can be beneficial. “I think there’s certainly some promising effects with supplements and a lot of what we know about pain in general comes from the plant world, like some of the classic analgesics that we’ve been using for centuries.” 

McDougall and Appleton discussed the science behind the most-talked about treatments people turn to to help relieve osteoarthritis symptoms: omega-3 fatty acids, curcumin, glucosamine and chondroitin. People try omega-3 fatty acids because it can help reduce inflammatory markers (which is one of the reasons why it’s good for heart health). But at doses of two to three grams of combined EPA and DHA a day in many trials, omega-3s don’t seem to show consistent benefits for those with osteoarthritis. As for glucosamine – one of the natural building blocks the body uses to make the cartilage tissue matrix – the theory is straightforward says Appleton: “If you supply more raw material, maybe the body uses it to maintain or repair cartilage, and glucosamine may also have a mild anti-inflammatory effect within the joint.” So far, trials have been inconsistent in humans and there remains no “credible human evidence that any oral supplement regrows cartilage or reverses the structural changes of osteoarthritis. At best, some may slightly ease pain and inflammation, but it’s a different claim than ‘repairing’ the joint,’” he explains. 

One supplement Appleton says is showing genuine promise is curcumin, the active compound in turmeric. “It works through some of the same inflammatory pathways as anti-inflammatory medications, but less potently. The catch is that plain turmeric is very poorly absorbed, so the newer ‘bioavailability-enhanced’ formulations are what’s driving more encouraging recent results,” he says, cautioning that it’s still too early to recommend it to patients – there needs to be larger, more rigorous, independently funded trials first.  

Collagen peptides recently entered the osteoarthritis discussion and there have been several placebo-controlled trials in the past couple of years. Several found improvements in knee pain and function over a few months of daily use. “The idea is that these smaller, digestible collagen fragments may signal the body’s own cartilage-forming cells to ramp up production. It’s an interesting early signal, but trials so far are very small,” he says. 

The bottom line here is that there’s just not enough evidence to show that supplements can really make a difference when it comes to truly easing pain caused by osteoarthritis. “And the modest pain benefits seem very small compared with things we know actually help the joint itself – staying active, building strength around the joint, lowering weight if that’s relevant and using medical therapies when needed,” says Appleton. “Supplements, at best, might be a modest add-on but are not a replacement for core osteoarthritis management.” 

Zoomer Rx

If you’re interested in trying a supplement, talk to your healthcare provider or pharmacist first, especially if you’re already taking prescription medications. People on blood thinners who take glucosamine and chondroitin have an increased risk of bleeding, and curcumin has a similar caution. There are also adverse effects for people on antiplatelet drugs who take omega-3s, and turmeric can interfere with iron absorption and other meds. “Plants and natural compounds are still biologically active – that’s the whole reason they might help pain in the first place,” says Appleton. “Being plant-derived doesn’t exempt something from causing side effects or interacting with medications, and the lighter regulatory bar for supplements means quality control varies more than people may assume.”