Home Base: New York, N.Y.
Author’s Take: “I called my agent and I said, I’m thinking of writing a sequel to The Plot. And she said, “Yes, and we’re going to call it The Sequel. And I just started laughing. It was such a great title and such a great idea that I almost had to do it as a result.”
Favourite Line: “She was alone in the Ripley Inn, a failing establishment in a failing town beside an already failed college that once employed and pretended to educate failed writers, and all was right with the world.”
Review: When I read about The Sequel, the concept was so ingenious I ran out and bought The Plot, and what a treat to read the two novels back to back. In the first book, which came out in 2021 and is now being made into a TV series, Jacob Finch Bonner dies by suicide after someone threatens to expose him as a plagiarist. He stole the idea for his wildly successful third novel, Crib, from Vermont creative-writing student Evan Parker, who died before he could publish it. At the end, Anna, widowed after an all-too-brief marriage to Jake, goes on the Crib book tour in his stead, mainly to ensure the royalties keep rolling into her, the beneficiary of his literary estate. For lack of anything new to say at one book event, she mentions she might try her hand at writing, too.
“First of all, it wasn’t that hard,” Anna Williams-Bonner explains in the first line of The Sequel, which picks up as Jake’s agent, the much sought-after Matilda Salter, delivers good news: not only will she publish The Afterword, Anna is a “gifted writer.”
As The Sequel unfolds, it becomes increasingly clear someone still knows about Parker’s unpublished manuscript when, a few weeks into Anna’s book tour for The Afterword, the anonymous accusations start up again. That’s when Anna’s backstory starts to unravel.
The Sequel’s slow drip of small reveals stopped me in my tracks, so much so that I would go back and reread sentences to see if I had imagined the clues. On the first page, as Anna explains how she learned about the publishing industry by watching Jake write Crib, Korelitz writes, “she’s come away from it with a highly nuanced understanding of how that extraordinary book had been made, its specific synthesis of fiction (his) and fact (her own).” Her own fact? Wait! What? Then this: “It had been years since a living person on the planet had been fully aware of who she was, and that she was not a childless woman in her late thirties brought up in Idaho, named Anna Bonner-Williams, and before that, Anna Williams.”
The writing is sly, hilarious and meta-referential. When Matilda suggests Anna should write a sequel to The Afterword, Anna replies, “but they’re never as good as the first books, are they?”
As Anna’s story is revealed and – like Jake in The Plot – she embarks on a quest to expose their tormentors, the bodies pile up and the suspense builds to a denouement I didn’t see coming, even though it was right there in front of my eyes, all along.—K.H.